Stocks Are Cheaper Than Anyone Realizes

Money managers aren't so different from individual investors.

They're always trying to figure out if stocks are expensive... or if they've discovered an imbalance in valuations ahead of everyone else.

After all, the name of the game on Wall Street is performance relative to expectations. You want to find the deals no one else sees. But as today's market shows, it's important to look at this in the right way.

Wall Street's best are always trying to look at where the economy and the market are headed... not where they've been. Consequently, they're looking at least six to eight months out.

Meanwhile, the financial media gets caught up in the "here and now." That confuses individual investors, because it's the opposite of how they should be thinking. And right now, it's causing lots of folks to miss the opportunity in the market.

Let me explain...

If we were to get caught up in the "here and now" thinking of the media, we'd look at the S&P 500 Index's current valuations. The current multiple of 22.16 times earnings is worrisome. But it's also a look in the rearview mirror.

If we look at the same index's valuation from a forward 12-month perspective, like asset managers, we'd see it sits at 18.9 times earnings. (In other words, that's what you get if you base it on the expected earnings over the next year.)

Now, some would argue that's still expensive. But it's much more reasonable than the current multiple. And if we look out two years, we'd see a 17.2 times multiple... while in three years, it's just a 15.5 times multiple. Take a look...

This tells us that analysts expect earnings growth to pick from here. And based on those expectations, the market looks even cheaper than most realize.

The next question we have to ask is, are these future earnings estimates reasonable?

Based on what we know, they're more than reasonable... They're too low.

Coming into the last two quarters, Wall Street analysts lowered their earnings estimates. Heading into the third quarter of 2019, analysts were pessimistic again – they predicted a decline of 4.6%. (The actual figure came in at a drop of 2.3%.)

This past quarter was no different. At the beginning of the fourth quarter, Wall Street stock pickers started out expecting 2.5% earnings growth. Those expectations have since dropped to a decline of 1.9%. With all the negativity we've seen from analysts, the actual result may be closer to unchanged or slightly positive.

It's easy to see why they became so cautious... A big driver was the perilous state of trade negotiations between the U.S. and China. No one knew what the costs would be or how the tariffs would affect consumer spending.

Companies haven't helped. Given the uncertainty around trade, they've been cautious about their business outlooks, too. They didn't know if they would have to uproot their manufacturing processes and move them to other countries.

The safest bet for both corporate America and analysts everywhere was to expect the worst. Consequently, numbers more or less came down across the board. And as earnings numbers dropped, it pushed the valuation multiple of the S&P 500 Index and other indexes higher.

That's why stocks are cheaper than anyone believes today. Estimates have come down based on problems that are now largely in the rearview mirror. Looking ahead, the picture is much brighter than folks expect.

The U.S. and China just signed the phase one trade deal, which should cause tension and uncertainty to ease. Companies now have a better handle on what their costs are going to look like.

As a result, the corporate guidance that was based on the worst-case scenario can change. And that should provide continued support for the S&P 500.

It's one more reason why staying bullish is the right call today.

Good investing,

C. Scott Garliss

Editor's note: It's time to look past the headlines... For free news and commentary on what's really happening in the markets, sign up for Stansberry NewsWire today. Scott and his team de-mystify the world of investing and share insights you won't get from the mainstream media, with daily recaps, market snapshots, and more. Click here for more details.

Further Reading

"You can always come up with an excuse to NOT put your money to work," Steve writes. There's no denying that stocks have gone up a lot in recent years. But that doesn't mean they can't soar much higher from here... Read the full story: How to Start Out in Stocks – Here at Record Highs.

"If you made this mistake, well, join the crowd," Whitney Tilson says. It's easy to pass on a stock you were considering only to see it march to new highs. But if you know what really matters, you can avoid falling into this same trap... Learn more here: The Three Most Dangerous Words in Investing.

Market Notes
EVOLVING WITH THE TIMES TO CREATE A TURNAROUND STORY

Today’s company is showing how flexible businesses can survive big changes…

When Apple (AAPL) released the iPhone in 2007, it turned the world on its head. Folks could go online anywhere – and soon, almost everyone had the free Google Maps app to help them get around. That was bad news for GPS company Garmin (GRMN). No one needed its car-navigation devices anymore, and its shares fell off a cliff. But the company found new ways to prosper…  

Garmin got its tracking technology into new sectors, like fitness. Today, it has wearables that can track your heartbeat and even go underwater with you while you swim. Its products hold their own against wearables from Apple and Fitbit (FIT). And this strategy is still going strong… Last quarter, Garmin’s aviation, fitness, outdoor, and marine segments collectively increased 24% year over year. Sales reached $934 million, up 15% over the same period.

As you can see, GRMN shares are steadily rising. They’re up around 130% over the past three years, including dividends. If companies are creative, they can thrive even in the face of a relentless new technology trend…